Photo
Popularity Rate down 0wattwatters who think this pulse is not really interesting Rate up 2wattwatters who think this pulse is interesting

What about the risks of the efficient light bulbs?

Juan Ignacio Galimberti on January 8, 2008 | 1154 Views | 5 Comments

Well, I have been reading about that, but there isn’t enough information about the risk of this efficiency bulb kin relationship with the final disposal and the hazardous when it brakes.What about in your countries?Here in Argentina the government is encouraging a campaign giving 2 efficient light bulbs to every home with the idea of reduce the consumption and use this energy to the industry. But we really know which the environmental and health impacts are?I know that worldwide the tendency is change all the bulb for efficient light bulbs to 2011 so, what are the countries doing in this subject? I would like you give me your opinions?

 

|

5 Comments

#1 by Cons Ortheil on January 9, 2008 at 6:22 a.m.

Here in Australia local authorities like to avoid that issue. There are some recyclers who can recycle these light bulbs, however they usually will not accept low volumes, as they specialise in commercial flourescent tube disposal.

 

There are tips on what to do when compact flourescent lightbulbs (CFL's) break accidentally.

 1) Air out the room if possible

2) Get a damp cloth to wipe up the mess

3) Throw it all in a bin.

 

The best option in my opinion is to have CFL collection bins in central public places, much like glass bottle disposal collection points. 

Photo #2 by John Kalyesubula on January 16, 2008 at 7:30 a.m.

I totally agree with Ortheil on this.Another point to note is that not much has been done or even said about CFL disposal in some countries, like in Uganda  where I come from

Photo #3 by Jack Sheldon on January 17, 2008 at 2:39 p.m.

I entirely agree with the views made here. CFLs are hazardous and contain substances, notably mercury, which are normally only allowed in controlled environements. I recently drew attention of a Swiss politician, Jacques Neirynck, who had promoted CFLs to this problem and his response:

Le problème est identique pour les piles et batteries qui sont maintenant récupérées dans une large mesure. D'une façon générale, tout le matériel électrqiue doit être impérativement recyclé et on y arrive.

is totally meaningless and unhelpful. It has taken us decades to get the levels of recycling we have today and even in Switzerland (apparently the world champions in this area), we only get to less than 80% of batteries recycled. If in 20 years we get to that figure, then there are still an awful lot of CFLs which will have been dumped in the open and released significant amounts of a highly toxic substance.

What concerns me most is not so much the use of CFLs and their disposal. It is possible to recycle CFLs and there are commercial companies doing so today. If nothing else, throw a bit of money at the problem and you will come up with the technology to solve the problem. The real issue is a societal issue. The vast majority of the population has no idea that CFLs contain a toxic substance, the need for recycling is either missing (usually) or only printed on the packaging - and who keeps the packaging for light bulbs?

In my opinion the campaign for CFLs must include information on the need to recycle CFLs at the end of life and on precautions to take if they are damaged during use.

Photo #4 by Pippa Rojo on January 17, 2008 at 5:26 p.m.

Thought I'd pitch in and translate the quote in French above:

"The problem is the same with batteries. most of which are now retrieved. On the whole, anything electrical has to be recycled and we're getting there".

 What a non-committal comment. What does he mean by "we're getting there" which could also be translated by "we manage"? Does he mean we've still got to make an effort or is he giving himself or the Swiss a pat on the back? The UK certainly doesn't manage very well. Most batteries still go in to landfill with the rest of the trash and then they cover it with a layer of top soil and grow salads on it. You might end up eating lettuce grown biologically (ha!) feeding on battery juice.

I'm being cynical.

Matters very little what Jacques means. I think we ought to supply all national standardization organizations with the means to generate simple recycled boxes which could be sent out to schools to underline the importance, not only using efficient lighting, but also ensuring that the bulbs get disposed of correctly.

Give them graphics, correct information and the recycling box and the message could get passed on to parents. Switzerland is champion in recycling but I haven't heard of any campaign on that front yet.

Photo #5 by Joshua Jones on January 18, 2008 at 12:45 p.m.

Thought you might be interested in this http://www.asimpleswitch.com/?country=us site from Philips in the US. It asks the consumer to commit to changing their incandescent  bulbs to a Philips enegy saving bulbs and shows the impact on the reduction of coal power stations. Nothing about safe disposal but a good start. Wouldn't some sort of bulb amnesty work better? Couldn't a retailer like Wal-Mart offer a trade in on those bulbs and then help people understand how to dispose of the new bulbs safely?

Related pulses

Slowly turning green

Bill Thompson on August 12, 2008 | 245 Views
  An interesting survey into attitudes towards green computing from CDW's ITMonitor shows that while the majority of US "IT decision makers" think green issues are important, there are many ...

ECO-ICONIC products coming our way

Laurent Haug on May 6, 2008 | 846 Views
TrendWatching thinks that we're entering the eco-iconic era, where people buy green products because it brings them more points on the social ladder. That's a pretty powerful driver ...

New energy source discovered….

Mat Feakins on March 27, 2008 | 1145 Views
As our petro-economies lights go out we are forced to look at as many of the different options of renewable energy that are available. This weeks Anglo French nuclear talks ...

The Offline Cost of our Online Lives

Bill Thompson on March 23, 2008 | 844 Views
This is my latest column for the BBC News website, where I write about technology issues each week.  I thought it might be of interest to fellow wattwatters. The next ...

Nigeria 'energy savings day'......

Franklin Ossuetta on March 2, 2008 | 1049 Views
This is a pretty hard scenario to imagine.....or picture. The situation in Nigeria is so poor that we hardly have enough for domestic or industrial consumption....to even think ...

UK energy saving day...uses more energy

Jonathan Buck on February 29, 2008 | 1022 Views
Perhaps the role of the individual in making a difference in improving electrical energy efficiency is a lost cause, or is it about who pushes out the message? Take this ...

Electricity is vital

Pippa Rojo on January 31, 2008 | 802 Views
The China Daily reported yesterday that two more people had died in attempting to assure transmission of electricity to the Chinese population besieged with snow and ice. That Premier Wen ...

Smart Meters

Cons Ortheil on January 21, 2008 | 1045 Views
I come from a part of Australia which has very old meters which will soon be upgraded. I was wondering if anyone on this forum is able to discuss smart ...

Are you prone to green compensation?

Jonathan Buck on January 15, 2008 | 812 Views
Just read an excellent blog from Paul Horrell on the BBC's new site www.loveearth.com . He makes the point of individuals green compensating one way (say, buying a ...

Green Buildings Video Stories in Australia

Christian Bertolini on January 10, 2008 | 901 Views
We are a video and multimedia production company (Pumpkin Productions) and we are producing a website ( www.doyougreen.com ) about Green Stories in Australia, and in other parts of the ...

New website SmartPlanet has launched

Ethical Angel on November 6, 2007 | 810 Views
 Another green website with promise has launched!   www.SmartPlanet.com Their description is here: " SmartPlanet is your one-stop guide to creating a smarter, greener and fairer planet. We're bringing ...

Tim O'Reilly wonders at the profligacy of US electricity consumption

Bill Thompson on November 3, 2007 | 885 Views
A lovely little post from publisher and general Web guru Tim O'Reilly over at the O'Reilly Radar blog. He is visiting Sicily and wonders at how different it ...

New US site tells you to "get energy active"

Jonathan Buck on October 25, 2007 | 811 Views
Just added to the US wikiwatts entries ( wattwatt.com/wikiwatts ), check out this site (getenergyactive.org) which is backed by the Edison Electric Institute (EEI). As it says: "Electricity. It ...

Local "grassroots" competitions

Laila Briquet-Mosig on October 11, 2007 | 826 Views
Getting the individual to realize whan impact small changes in their lives can have on energy consumption is not easy.  Grassroots competitions can inspire people to make changes in their ...

Ej: de etiqueta

Juan Ignacio Galimberti on October 4, 2007 | 918 Views